Home >Insurance Quotes Health > Jeffersonville disputes insurance contract - Chicago Tribune
Jeffersonville disputes insurance contract - Chicago Tribune
Posted on Thursday, May 10, 2012 by Insurance Quotes Health
JEFFERSONVILLE —
Just days before leaving office at the end of last year, former Jeffersonville Mayor Tom Galligan signed a two-year insurance contract with Preferred Health Plan.
However, members of Jeffersonville's new administration, under Mayor Mike Moore, said they don't plan to keep it, claiming the document is invalid.
"Indiana law does not allow for a municipality to enter into contracts that are unfunded," city attorney Les Merkley said in a press release. "By entering into this two-year contract as it left office, the prior administration committed tax dollars beyond the existing budget. State law says such contracts are unfunded, and therefore void."
Merkley said he's sent Preferred Health a letter to that effect but has yet to receive a response.
The Jeffersonville City Council creates an annual budget, which provides money for insurance. However, those budgets only cover one calendar year, not two.
Does that mean every two-year contract is invalid?
"There are exceptions," Merkley said.
Indiana statue 36-4-8-12, refers to contracts limited to the amount of appropriation but mentions exceptions such as long-term contracts for utility services or for issuing bonds.
According to Merkley, Galligan signed the deal Dec. 28, 2011, just three days before Moore took office. Further, he said, the city has been unable to find any records of Jeffersonville's Board of Public Works and Safety ever approving the contract, which Merkley said raises more questions about its validity.
"This is another legal requirement before a contract with a municipality is valid. The mayor cannot unilaterally enter into contracts on behalf of the city without proper authorization."
Galligan said he was given approval by the board of public works before signing it.
"Everything I did was approved," Galligan said in a phone interview.
The former mayor said he had to sign it by the end of the year in order to make sure city employees had insurance coverage at the start of 2012.
Edward Culpepper Cooper was the city's insurance agent of record at the time. Cooper -- who insisted that this article specifically denote that he is not a lawyer and is not interpreting the contract -- said he brokered the deal and he, too, remembers the board authorizing Galligan to approve it.
"I was there," he said.
He was not sure about the date in which that permission was granted.
Merkley said it's not mentioned in any of the meeting minutes and one meeting audio tape from December is missing.
Apart from it being invalid, Merkley calls it a bad deal for the city because of the way the out clause is worded. Apparently, the city can end the contract with 30 days notice but still has to pay Preferred Health.
"[Galligan] entered into a contract that said we can get rid of you PHP, but we still got to pay you," he said. "It's absurd."
The city only found out that the contract existed a few weeks ago.
In late April, the new board of public works -- which includes Moore -- took a vote to switch insurance carriers, going from Preferred Health to Humana starting July 1. When Merkley called Preferred Health to inform them about the switch, he was informed of the contract.
Merkley said the switch to Humana is supposed to save the city $800,000 in the first year alone. However, that's only an estimate, as the cost is based on how many claims are actually filed.
"This savings is significant. In this tough economy, taxpayers deserve to know that their dollars are spent wisely," Moore said in a press release. "It's unfortunate that had the city been with Humana this year, we would have spent far less on health insurance."
Preferred health did not return a phone call request for comment on this story by press time.
The contract wasn't the only one Galligan signed in the closing days of his administration. He also signed a $134,600 contract with Construction Solutions to oversee work at Vissing Park about eight days before leaving office.
Further, Galligan signed an employment contract with former Redevelopment Director T.J. Justice just before last November's election.
11 May, 2012
-
Source: http://news.google.com/news/url?sa=t&fd=R&usg=AFQjCNH69w2uAdGIaIO8DuqkPK1tBfvOyg&url=http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/sns-mct-jeffersonville-disputes-insurance-contract-20120510,0,4101019.story
--
Manage subscription | Powered by rssforward.com
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(463)
-
▼
May
(449)
- [insurance quotes health] New comment on Liquor Li...
- American Integrity Insurance Achieves Company Reco...
- Backers of health insurance rate regulation edge c...
- Backers of health insurance rate regulation edge c...
- KCPD Releases Pics In Insurance Office Burglary - ...
- Group gathers enough signatures for insurance rate...
- A.M. Best Affirms Ratings of Ardellis Insurance Lt...
- AM Best Affirms Ratings of Ardellis Insurance Ltd....
- Farmers Insurance Announces Partnership With the G...
- five Things to consider When Shopping for South Fl...
- Doctors, Healthcare Providers Denounce Proposed He...
- Costco Heads To $91 Selling Health Insurance Along...
- Price-Gouged Patients, Insurance Commissioner & Co...
- Farmers Insurance Announces Partnership With the G...
- Farmers Insurance Announces Partnership With the G...
- Price-Gouged Patients, Insurance Commissioner … - ...
- Flood Insurance Program Still in Limbo - Wall Stre...
- Flood Insurance Program Still in Limbo - Wall Stre...
- Friday Business Update: Facebook finally goes publ...
- NY hearings on 'forced' insurance in foreclosure -...
- Fate of 'uninsurables' hinges on Supreme Court - N...
- VIDEO: Special counsel and insurance counsel intro...
- Basler Sees Serbian Insurance Market Doubling in S...
- AM Best Affirms Ratings of Jupiter Insurance Limit...
- Michigan CO-OP Awarded $72 Million to Provide Heal...
- Spanish Debt Insurance Costs Hit New High - Wall S...
- Woodhome Insurance Group Offers Comprehensive Insu...
- Michigan CO-OP Awarded $72 Million to Provide Heal...
- Catholic college dropping student health-insurance...
- Fate of 'uninsurables' hinges on Supreme Court - C...
- Travel Insured is Named the 2012 US Insurance Prov...
- Basler Sees Serbian Insurance Market Doubling in S...
- ING's Asia life insurance sale shifts into top gea...
- NY hearings on 'forced' insurance in foreclosure -...
- Travel insurance FAQ: Buying a policy, filing clai...
- Scars from Hurricane Andrew still haunt Florida's ...
- Travel insurance FAQ: Buying a policy, filing clai...
- NY hearings on 'forced' insurance in foreclosure -...
- The Health Insurance Group Completes its Company P...
- CORRECTED-UPDATE 1-ING's Asia life insurance sale ...
- MetLife China sees strong insurance demand - Marke...
- Do You Need A Rental Car Insurance Policy? - 1UP.COM
- UPDATE 1-Reinsurer Axis Capital names XL Insurance...
- ACE Announces New Leaders for UK and Ireland Retai...
- MetLife China sees strong insurance demand - Marke...
- Local windstorm insurance board member, legislator...
- House insurance gouge puts homes in danger - New Y...
- Bids for ING's Asian Life Insurance Due Friday - W...
- State Farm Insurance pays $109M for dog bite claim...
- Ohio school cuts insurance, birth control coverage...
- Citizens Property Insurance's board chairman wants...
- One Year After Joplin Tornadoes $2.16 Billion In I...
- Arizona eyes new role on health insurance reviews ...
- NY hearings on 'forced' insurance in foreclosure -...
- Bids for ING's Asian Life Insurance Due Friday - W...
- Arizona eyes new role on health insurance reviews ...
- For Disability Insurance Awareness Month, MR Insur...
- MADD Canada Urges Canadians to Keep This Long Week...
- 30-day flood insurance program extension to be vot...
- Life Insurance Providers Could Benefit by Increasi...
- 30-day flood insurance program extension to be vot...
- New Citizens insurance customers could face 56 per...
- Does it make sense to buy cancer insurance? - Fox ...
- TEXT-S&P summary: Gulf Insurance Co. KSC - Reuters
- Life Insurance Providers Could Benefit by Increasi...
- Allstate Insurance Company Files $14 Million Insur...
- Bring the insurance back to employment insurance -...
- Chicago man gets 3 years in insurance fraud case -...
- Texas Windstorm Insurance board approves 5 percent...
- Dog bite claims cost insurers $497M in 2011, insur...
- Apollo Munich offers affordable health insurance s...
- Citizens Insurance challenges law on rate hikes - ...
- Health Insurance Infographics By HealthCompare Are...
- Miami has highest healthcare costs in country for ...
- Understanding Health Insurance Exchanges - Medscape
- U.S. Rep Miller: We Need to Eliminate the National...
- State receives new grant for health insurance mark...
- Insurance Networking News, Celent Announce Top Tec...
- Bring the insurance back to employment insurance -...
- New Citizens insurance customers could face 54 per...
- Spanish Debt Insurance Costs Rise, Bond Auction Ey...
- European Debt Insurance Costs Rise Ahead Of Spanis...
- Insurance Australia considers sale of UK assets - ...
- Moneymaxim Re-launch Updated car Hire Insurance Co...
- Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones Announces Good N...
- According to CheapAutoInsurance.org California Adj...
- State Farm Insurance paid $109 million for dog bit...
- State Farm Insurance paid $109 million for dog bit...
- Healthcare Business News Insurance exchanges could...
- Storms a year ago among most costly ever, insuranc...
- Ambac Judge Asked by Wisconsin Insurance Chief to ...
- Health Insurance Infographics By HealthCompare Are...
- Dhipaya Insurance, Seafco, Tata Steel: Thailand Eq...
- Insurance Australia may sell U.K. operations - Mar...
- Long-Term Care Insurance Set to Expand Rapidly as ...
- Fifth insurance bill passes Legislature - Everythi...
- Dhipaya Insurance, Seafco, Tata Steel: Thailand Eq...
- Insurance Australia Considers Selling UK Operation...
- Scammers collected insurance on same burned furnit...
- Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones Announces Good N...
-
▼
May
(449)